• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

GingerGarner.com

EudeMOMia | Integrative Physical Therapy and Lifestyle Medicine

  • View DrGingerGarner’s profile on Facebook
  • View MedicalTherapeuticYoga’s profile on Instagram
  • View GingerGarner’s profile on YouTube
  • View gingergarner’s profile on Vimeo
  • Home
  • About
  • Learn
    • Events
    • Blog
    • Publications & Affiliations
    • Podcasts & Interviews
    • Videos
    • Yoga Therapist Training
    • Yoga Teacher Training
    • Courses
      • Attend a Course
      • Host A Course
    • Anti-Aging Resources
    • Mothering Resources
  • Patients
  • Connect

Health Care a Basic Human Right: A Worldview of the Four Systems

brokenhealthcareHealth Care a Basic Human Right: A Worldview of the Four Systems of Health Care

I am continuously saddened by the lack of quality health care offered in America. Barriers to receipt of health care are higher than ever. I have seen terrible things delivered in the name of “medicine” over my 15+ short years of practice. I want to see that terrible health care change.

  • Patients today are being denied benefits when they clearly need them.
  • Medicare recipients being given “bottom dollar” care because that is all that is “afforded” to them.
  • Therapists and physicians alike barely touch or speak with a patient and instead issue drugs, tests, or procedures with minimal long-term benefit, or worse, short-term gain but long-term loss.
  • Therapists and physicians alike also barely speak to another another, which poses the common risk of a patient missing critical care that they truly need. I see this happening over and over again in physical therapy. A new mother doesn’t receive the care she needs in the prenatal or postpartum period, which sets her up for a lifetime of aches and pains which could have been prevented if she had received physical therapy after childbirth. See my article on Why Every New Mom Needs PT .

Further, the US has an increasing gap between cost and efficiency.1 Meaning the US is increasingly inefficient with the health care it delivers, meanwhile costs are soaring.1,2

“In other words, the world’s richest country spends more of its money on health care while getting less than almost every other nation in return”.1,2

I do want to be clear though. No one person is specifically is to blame. We inherited an enormous “machine” of a system that was already broken. Our generation is simply recognizing the great (and urgent) need for its repair.

Health care should be a basic human right.

Fortunately, we have helpful texts like T.R. Reid’s, “The Healing of America,” in which he describes the four types of health care models or systems, which clarify the motley crew of a system that currently possesses the American medical landscape.3  The four systems include3:

  1. The Beveridge Model – Health care provided and financed by the government through tax payments.3
  2. The Bismarck Model – Health care provided via insurers called “sickness funds” funded by employers and employees through payroll deductions.3
  3. The National Health Insurance Model – A combination of Beveridge and Bismarck Models.3
  4. The Out of Pocket Model – You can have health care only if you can afford it. Reid’s book states that the US is unlike any other country because it “maintains so many systems for many separate classes of people.” In this way, the US is “like rural India” for those 15% of uninsured Americans.3

It is a shame that America’s uninsured are in the same situation as the poor from third-world countries3 – starving, sick, and dying just because they lack basic access to quality health care.  The American poor end up using hospital ER’s for their primary care because they lack the funds to pay for health care insurance. Many simply go untreated due to the “out-of-pocket” model.3  In determining which model may be ideal, I decided to look up what citizens thought of their health care models and ended up landing on the Bismarck model as the most unobstrusive because it could allow for uninterrupted benefits to Americans, while affording all Americans coverage.  It could also function to facilitate increased consumer responsibility for health, so long as accurate health beliefs and proper utilization of health care providers in front-line medicine could be established (i.e. PT’s as a primary care provider for back pain).  I found two articles that spoke to the satisfaction(s) and frustration(s) of citizens in Germany and Switzerland.

Pros of Swiss system1:

  • Universal coverage through insurance purchase by citizens
  • No cost past monthly premium and deductible – and may adjust the premium or deductible cost include less/more coverage and private rooms/private hospitals
  • Disability insurance for children and adults provides even more benefits
  • Insurance companies cannot make a profit under Swiss law
  • Most beneficiaries choose their own providers
  • 99.5% of Swiss are insured.5

Cons of Swiss system6:

  • Everyone pays the same rates regardless of income, which could be a hardship for those making less income
  • Rising cost of subsidies provided by government

The investigative journalist interviewed German and German-American dual citizens, who said, “the health care system in America is the major reason why we have never moved there, and never will move there.”6 That is a strong indictment of the poor state of American health care.

Pros of German system6:

  • Most of funding from insurance system comes from premiums paid by workers and employers, not from taxes
  • Generous health benefits with “little to no wait” for surgery or diagnostic tests
  • House calls and direct access to speak with doctors via phone
  • Insurance companies will pay for household/keeping support when you are recovering from illness or are disabled
  • Premiums based on salary
  • Low co-pays and low premiums, even including orthodontics
  • Insurance company cannot raise rates on an individual if they get sick or increase premiums as they age. Insurers also must control costs.
  • No one is uninsured in the 125 year-old history of the system.

Cons of German system6:

  • The self-employed can opt out of system and pay to have better coverage (go to the front of the line, receive private rooms, chooses who he wants to see, etc.).
  • There is an 8% tax on gross income to a nonprofit insurance company called “sickness fund.” (However, that isn’t really a “con.”)
  • German employers pay 8% of premiums, whereas US employers pay around 18% (but Americans have more expensive healthcare with less overall good health and outcomes), again not really a con.

This post is not an endorsement of any one health care system, as the problem of health care in this country is complex and deeply broken. This article does serve as just one more indictment of the shameful state of our current health care system. It also serves to inform and encourage the “citizen-as-health-care-consumer” (rather than citizen as helpless or passive patient with no voice) to stand up and ask for the health care that by birth, you deserve.

 

 

References

  1. Davidson, KA. The Most Efficient Health Care Systems in the World. (Infographic). The Huffington Post. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/08/29/most-efficient-healthcare_n_3825477.html. Last accessed November 5, 2013.
  2. World Development Indicators database, World Bank, 23 September 2013.  Gross Domestic Product 2012. http://databank.worldbank.org/data/download/GDP.pdf. Last accessed November 5, 2013.
  3. Reid T.R. An Excerpt from The Healing of America: A Global Quest for Better, Cheaper, and Fairer Health Care. Penguin Press 2009.  http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/sickaroundtheworld/countries/models.html
  4. Rovner, J. In Switzerland, A Health Care Model for America? http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=92106731 Last accessed November 5, 2013.
  5. Roy, Avik. Why Switzerland Has the World’s Best Health Care System. http://www.forbes.com/sites/theapothecary/2011/04/29/why-switzerland-has-the-worlds-best-health-care-system/. Last accessed November 5, 2013.
  6. Knox, R. Most Patients Happy with German Health Care.  http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=92106731. Last accessed November 5, 2013.

Share this:

  • Reddit
  • More
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • WhatsApp
  • Tumblr
  • Print

Related

Filed Under: EudeMOMia | From Recovery to Discovery, Mindful Breath & Movement Tagged With: advocate for better health care, broken health care, fixing health care system, four health care systems, health care as a basic human right, patient advocacy, worldview of health care

Free videos and book excerpt! Join the transformation…

Enter your email address here to sign up for updates from Dr. G, as well as to receive an excerpt from the Medical Therapeutic Yoga book and a special link for free access to dozens of videos in the Medical Therapeutic Yoga video library.

Previous Post: « Earth Day is Our Day
Next Post: The Yoga Couch, Part 2 »

Reader Interactions

Leave a comment... Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

Meet Dr. G

Meet Dr. G

Hello and welcome to EudeMOMia! I'm Dr. Ginger Garner, a mother of 3 & longtime physical therapist and athletic trainer in women's health. I know what it's like to have to overcome poor health & healthcare, and my goal is to empower & advocate for you to help you move from recovery after birth to discovery of your best self! Learn more...

Mindful Living

Mindfulness & Relationships
Mothers' Rights & Research
Mindful Breath & Movement
Mindful Music

Healthy Living

Spine Health
Shoulder Health
Hip & Pelvic Health
Gut Health

Related

Testimonials


Brian C. Kittelson, PT, Minnesota

My wife and I both took your yoga PYT course in the 90s in Minneapolis Minnesota.  I just wanted to let you know that I…


Read more

Meagan Satinsky PT, PYT-C

Hi Ginger! After having some time to digest the (Professional Yoga Therapist) training last week at Emerald Isle I wanted to drop you a note…


Read more

Ruth Hulette, DOM, PYT-C

Thank you for your thoughtful and encouraging feedback. I found myself feeling quite sad when I walked away today and realized I only have one…


Read more

PYT-C from Module 8

Ginger is an amazing instructor and her passion is contagious. This program gives me hope for healthcare.


Read more

Dr. Tawna Wilkinson, PT, DPT, PhD, PCS

Ginger, Being in your presence the past several days (at Module 8/Yoga as Medicine I) has provided such a light for me for many reasons.…


Read more

Recent Patient with Ginger

Ginger is working with a postpartum mom with multiple conditions, including second degree tear, vestibulitis, dyspareunia, DRA, non relaxing pelvic floor, back and hip pain,…


Read more

Barb Rabin, PT, ATC, PYT

That pink house on the beach was a safe haven where I met all these awesome caring friends and most of all you Ginger Garner…


Read more

Angie Cooper, Swansboro, NC

Thank you Ginger….thank you, thank you…..for introducing me to yoga. It has been the best thing I’ve ever done for my body and my mind…


Read more

Wendy, PT, PYT-C

Thank you for revolutionizing healthcare — I am so honored and proud to be a part of this pioneering movement! Raleigh, North Carolina


Read more

Debbie Peel, Swansboro, NC

I couldn’t recommend Ginger enough! She saved me from a second shoulder surgery. I am very impressed with the way she blends Western medicine with…


Read more

Don’t miss a thing.

Sign up for be in the know, including the latest news on events, how you can learn and study with Ginger, blogs and research on hip and women's health (but no spam!) all delivered right to your inbox.

Upcoming Events

  1. Medical Therapeutic Yoga: Foundations for Yoga Practice in Physical Therapy – Feb 21-22, 2020

    February 21, 2020 @ 5:00 pm - February 22, 2020 @ 5:30 pm
  2. Level I Certification

    Yoga as Lifestyle Medicine – Level I Certification – March 13-15, 2020 California

    March 13, 2020 - March 15, 2020
  3. Level I Certification

    Yoga as Lifestyle Medicine Level I Certification – May 1-3, 2020 Charlottesville

    May 1, 2020 - May 3, 2020

View All Events

Let’s Connect

  • View DrGingerGarner’s profile on Facebook
  • View MedicalTherapeuticYoga’s profile on Instagram
  • View GingerGarner’s profile on YouTube
  • View gingergarner’s profile on Vimeo

As featured in…

As featured in…

PODCASTS & LIVE BROADCASTS

View on Instagram

Footer

Quick Links

  • Media Kit
  • Testimonials
  • Events
  • Host A Course
  • Patients
  • Connect
  • Disclaimer

Recent Posts

  • Simple Ways to Sleep Better Tonight
  • Medical Therapeutic Yoga: Using “Windshield Wipers” to Assess & Improve Whole Body Health
  • Is it a Hip Labrum Retear? Plus Easy Hip Hacks & Yoga in Recovery (8 Week, Post 15)
  • Protecting the Sacroiliac Joint in Yoga, Part II
  • Protecting the Sacroiliac Joint in Yoga
  • Earth Day is Our Day
  • Manage Stress & Trauma with this Simple Daily Yoga Habit: The Sensory Diet

RSS The latest from PYTI

  • Mid-Term Essay Requirements
  • “This is What I Do” Series: A Sustainable Model for Healthcare Practice
  • Exit Exam
  • Midterm Exam
  • Revolved Chair Pose – Let the Knee Be Free
  • Recreating ‘Life at the Pink House’ At Home
  • A Meditation: my offering to all of us about to be impacted by Hurricane Florence

Copyright © 2019 Ginger Garner · Disclaimer · Website by Seaport Webworks. · Log in

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.